Ask

I have loyalty cards for three supermarkets and cycle between them for offers - has this saved anyone real money?

I tracked mine for a year because I had the same suspicion. The base earn rate on points came out under one percent of what I spent, which is worth having and is not worth planning your week around. The member-only prices were a different story and were worth several times the points - but only on a handful of items, and only when I would have bought them anyway. Once I subtracted fuel for the extra trips, the whole multi-shop routine was roughly break-even and cost me two hours a week.

189 · in/money-basics ·

Most of it is in a 401k and I want out at 52, what did people actually use to get money out before 59 and a half

I used substantially equal periodic payments for a while and I would not choose it again at 52 with your balances. It works, it removes the penalty, and it also locks you into a payment schedule that you break at real cost, which is exactly the flexibility you are retiring to get. It made sense when it was the only door available to me. With a taxable account holding several years of spending, you have better doors.

178 · in/early-retirement ·

Two index funds in my account overlap almost completely and I only noticed now

Don't sell, just stop buying. Redirect all new money into the cheaper fund and let the other one sit. You keep the tax deferred, the fee difference on existing holdings is usually small in absolute terms, and over a few years the cheaper fund becomes the majority of the position anyway.

Run the actual numbers before deciding, though. If the fee gap is 0.03% versus 0.05% on a £40k holding, that's £8 a year and absolutely not worth realising a gain over. If it's 0.05% versus 0.55%, that's a different conversation entirely.

689 · in/index-investing ·