Ask

Softener or iron filter first with 3 ppm iron and 18 grains hardness

Iron filter first, and put it ahead of wherever the softener eventually goes.

At 3 ppm you are well past what a softener is happy with. It will strip some of the iron, but iron fouls the resin bed, and a fouled bed stops removing hardness properly and starts smelling. You end up buying resin cleaner every month and replacing the bed years early.

With pH 7.4 and no sulphide, an air injection oxidising filter is the straightforward choice and it will land inside your budget with room to spare. It oxidises the iron, catches it in the media, and backwashes it to drain on a timer. Then the softener you buy next year sees clean water and lasts fifteen years.

176 · in/well-and-septic ·